Regenerative agriculture has the potential to improve animal welfare standards on-farm. Learn how these practices improve livestock health and quality of produce.

Notions of 'regenerative agriculture' have been circling farm enterprises for the last decade, and while many of the techniques employed in this holistic approach to farming are in no way new, they aim to improve biodiversity and overall land productivity. Most of the excitement around regenerative farming often focuses on improving soil health and boosting crop yields. However, an equally important yet sometimes overlooked aspect is its potential to significantly enhance animal welfare.

What does animal welfare mean, and why does it matter?

Animal welfare focuses on ensuring the wellbeing of livestock raised for meat, dairy or egg production. This comprises all aspects of life, including living conditions, the nutritional content of feed and the overall treatment and care of the animals.

In the rush to meet the growing demand for animal products, some farm enterprises may overlook the importance of animal welfare. Regenerative agriculture is a more holistic approach that focuses on all aspects of the land, striving to enhance farm efficiency, environmental changes and animal wellbeing. The challenge, however, lies in proving that regenerative practices are indeed boosting animal welfare.

Measuring animal welfare: Quantitative vs. qualitative data

There are 2 main types of data collection used in science: quantitative and qualitative.

Quantitative data refers to information that can be measured and expressed in numbers. This type of data is used to form scientific evaluations, such as changes in carbon sequestration levels or the nutritional content of soils.

Qualitative data refers to information gathered through the senses - sight, smell, touch, hearing and taste - and is often used for initial observations. When it comes to animal welfare, qualitative data is more common, but it's also more subjective, varying from person to person. This can make it challenging to prove scientifically that regenerative practices improve animal welfare.

Cattle fed high omega-6 grains produce more inflammatory fat, which is linked to increased chronic disease in humans.

It goes without saying that animals in any farming operation should be treated humanely. But beyond their deserved respect as another life form, it is also in our best interest to ensure high animal welfare standards. Substantial evidence shows the interconnectedness of human wellbeing and animal wellbeing. For instance, cattle fed high omega-6 grains produce more inflammatory fat, which is linked to increased chronic disease in humans (True Primal n.d.). Because the treatment of animals can be subjective, it's crucial to recognise that improving animal welfare is not only good for the animals but also beneficial for overall farm productivity and consumers.

If you are interested in better understanding the link between human and animal welfare, One Welfare is a community promoting 'interdisciplinary collaboration' for global agricultural objectives, such as food security and profitability, alongside quality animal welfare.

Enhancing animal welfare through regenerative practices: The science behind it

Across agricultural disciplines, many studies show that regenerative practices not only improve the natural landscape but also improve livestock welfare. Below are several examples.

Converting to multi-species pastures

Converting perennial dry grasses to a multi-species mix is a 'regenerative' technique that increases biodiversity and improves pasture health, among other benefits. Baker et al. (2023) show that compared to perennial ryegrass, a 6-species multi-species sward is more resilient to intensive beef grazing. Over their 2-year study, the multi-species mix produced more dry matter and required 55% less nitrogen input than the perennial species examined. Other studies also emphasise the ability of multi-species pastures to reduce reliance on nitrogen fertilisers while also providing micro- and macronutrients that may otherwise be lacking in the diet of ruminants (Cummins et al. 2021; Jaramillo et al. 2021). French (2017) also found that species-rich grasslands have higher concentrations of essential elements, including 56% more Phosphorus, 106% more Potassium, 183% more Calcium and 27% more protein than cereals and conventional hay.

Several studies show that grazing multi-species swards can substantially improve ewe and lamb health. Over a 2-year study, Grace et al. (2019) examined ewe and lamb performance across 4 different swards under rotational grazing management. Of the 4 study sites:

  • sward 1 consisted of a singular perennial ryegrass, Lolium perenne
  • sward 2 consisted of white clover and the perennial ryegrass Lolium perenne
  • swards 3 and 4 contained various combinations of grasses, legumes and herbs.
Ewes and lambs grazing multi-species swards had heavier live weights and better body condition scores.

Ewes and lambs grazing multi-species swards had heavier live weights and better body condition scores. Lambs also required less anthelmintic treatment than lambs who only grazed perennial ryegrass (who also took longer to meet slaughter weight).

Multi-species swards can also improve milk composition in dairy cows. Kostovska et al. (2024) compared the milk production of Holstein-Friesian and Jersey Holstein-Friesian cows grazing a multi-species sward system compared to a perennial ryegrass. Although the results differed for each breed, both showed improvements. Cows grazing multi-species pastures had increased creaming velocity values and increased total solids yield with higher levels of protein and fat.

Beyond improvements in body condition and animal productivity - which are clear signs of improved health - ruminants have also been found to self-medicate in diverse pasture systems. Studies show that multi-species forages allow ruminants to selectively graze crops that not only ensure their nutritional requirements are met but also counteract any effects from toxic secondary metabolites that might otherwise lead to nutritional disorders.

Silvopastoral systems

Silvopasture systems have been shown to improve rumination rates and reduce respiratory rates and body temperatures in livestock.

Silvopasture, the deliberate integration of trees and shrubs into livestock grazing land, is a regenerative technique that enhances windbreaks, biodiversity, soil conservation and overall landscape resilience. While this approach offers numerous environmental benefits and boosts land productivity, it also significantly improves animal welfare. Tree by-products used as feed can enhance the nutritional value of livestock diets, particularly during droughts (Jose and Dollinger 2019). Tree fodder has also been linked to increased livestock survival rates and body weight (Grebner et al. 2021). Additionally, silvopasture systems offer protection against wind, rain and frosts and provide animals with abundant shade, resulting in lower temperatures than in open pastures (Hayward 2021). In some cases, these systems have been shown to improve rumination rates and reduce respiratory rates and body temperatures in livestock compared to conventional grazing (Hayward 2021).

It's not just science; farmers agree!

Because of the complexities of the natural environment, it is often challenging for farmers to observe changes on-farm using numbers (quantitative data). Instead, observations are made based on what a farmer knows about his land and his animals (qualitative data). For this reason, hearing and learning from farmers is also important. In 2018, The Pasture Fed Livestock Association surveyed 59 farmers. Of them, 66% observed improvements in the health of their livestock after changing to regenerative farming techniques, stating they were relying less on antibiotics, wormers and other medicines (Hayward 2021).

Applying regenerative techniques that enhance landscape resilience and farm productivity can significantly improve animal welfare standards on your farm, leading to better livestock growth, survival rates and higher-quality produce. Practices that allow livestock to selectively feed, self-medicate, and provide shade and shelter under trees can greatly enhance their quality of life. However, to not only meet but exceed these welfare standards, it is crucial to have a thorough understanding of the animals' nutritional needs. Transitioning to holistic farming practices is not straightforward, and the appropriate techniques vary for every farm. Finding the right practices that match your farm's size and specific needs requires careful consideration, planning and guidance. Seeking advice from government extension officers or certified agronomists is an excellent way to begin your journey into regenerative agriculture, ensuring the links between human and animal welfare are healthy and positive.

References

Baker S, Lynch MB, Godwin F, Boland TM, Kelly AK, Evans ACO, Murphy PNC, Sheridan H (2023) 'Multispecies swards outperform perennial ryegrass under intensive beef grazing', Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 345, doi:10.1016/j.agee.2022.108335.

Cummins S, Finn JA, Richards KG, Lanigan GJ, Grange G, Brophy C, Cardenas LM, Misselbrook TH, Reynolds CK and Krol DJ (2021) 'Beneficial effects of multi-species mixtures on N2O emissions from intensively managed grassland swards', Science of The Total Environment, 792, doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.148163.

French KE (2017) 'Species composition determines forage quality and medicinal value of high diversity grasslands in lowland England', Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 241:193-204, doi:10.1016/j.agee.2017.03.012.

Grace C, Lynch MB, Sheridan H, Lott S, Fritch R and Boland TM (2019) 'Grazing multispecies swards improves ewe and lamb performance', Animal, 13(8):1721-1729, doi:10.1017/s1751731118003245.

Grebner DL, Bettinger P, Siry JP and Boston K, (2021) 'Introduction to Forestry and Natural Resources 2nd Edition', The Forestry Chronicle, 97(02):219, doi:10.5558/tfc2021-022.

Hayward H (2021) 'Regenerative Agriculture Practices Provide Benefits for Ruminant Health', Vet Sustain.

Jaramillo DM, Sheridan H, Soder K and Dubeux, JCB (2021) 'Enhancing the Sustainability of Temperate Pasture Systems through More Diverse Swards', Agronomy, 11(10):1912, doi:10.3390/agronomy11101912.

Jose S and Dollinger J (2019) 'Silvopasture: a sustainable livestock production system', Agroforestry Systems, 93(1):1-9, doi:10.1007/s10457-019-00366-8.

Kostovska R, Horan B, Drouin G, Tobin JT, O'Callaghan TF, Kelly AL and Gómez-Mascaraque LG (2024) 'Multispecies pasture diet and cow breed impacts on milk composition and quality in a seasonal spring-calving dairy production system', Journal of Dairy Science, doi:10.3168/jds.2024-24975.

True Primal (n.d.) 'Animal Welfare and Regenerative Agriculture', True Primal.